My apartment is on the first floor of a narrow building that was once a grocery store. So narrow, I have two entries with hallways:
a north door, below, where I often sit with my morning coffee. (That's my bike parked on the fence). I'd like to make a little patio of paving stones on the bare dirt...
And the official (mailbox) front door, facing the sunny south:
I'm halfway through reading the book ^ standing on my desk, Pioneer Girl (2014), by Bich Minh Nguyen.
It's good--interesting--about a young woman, Lee, born in the US to parents from Vietnam. Having finished her PhD in English, Lee is back home helping in the family restaurant, searching with no luck for an academic job--she can't even get a position as part-time adjunct faculty.
Through a fluke, Lee starts researching Rose Wilder Lane--the daughter of Laura Ingalls Wilder who edited and perhaps ghostwrote much of her mother's Little House series Lee grew up reading. She discovers that in 1965--this is fact!--RWL wrote a report for Woman's Day magazine from Vietnam, and this is where Lee imagines their histories intersecting. Was RWL the old, white woman customer of her grandfather's cafe, whom he always told stories about?
I know nothing about Rose Wilder Lane (RWL), and Pioneer Girl makes me curious. The good article "The Other Wilder: Rose Wilder Lane" (by Michael Zimny, South Dakota Public Broadcasting, 2017) quotes RWL writing of her own childhood:
“My father and mother were courageous, even gaily so. They did everything possible to make me happy, and I gaily responded with an effort to persuade them that they were succeeding.
But all unsuspected, I lived through a childhood that was a nightmare.
. . . I hated everything and everybody in my childhood with such bitterness and resentment that I didn’t want to remember anything about it.”
RW Lane became a journalist and traveled widely. What an interesting life! Later, she became a right-wing, Ayn Rand type.
In Vietnam, she saw correctly, "There is something in these people that isn’t explained, something that does not give up, that is not conquered.”
No kidding. However, she foresaw victory for that unrelentingness for the wrong side, the South.
Pioneer Girl isn't just about the search for RWL.
Bich Minh Nguyen weaves in Lee's childhood as a child of pioneers of a
different sort in the US Midwest.
All of this connects with my childhood, though I'm a generation older than the author. I grew up in Madison, Wisc. during the Sixties, and the Vietnam War was the backdrop of my childhood. I remember the antiwar protests in our streets and the war footage on our little black-and-white TV.
In those years, I read my sister's set of Little House books several
times, once when I was sick in bed--because they were there. They must have formed me, and they're are on my list of Children's Books
to Reread. Far down the list, though because I didn't love them.
I remember I did love how the LH books were about a girl learning how to make and do things--like The Island of the Blue Dolphins,
which I just reread.
Lee writes: the LH books were "a DIY guide to frontier living: how to make butter and cheese from the cow
you milked yourself; how to make sausage from the pig you butchered in
the yard; how to make a smooth pine floor and door with hinges; how to
sew a lady's dress with all the requisite flounces and bustles..."
Maybe there's too much cheerful can-do pluckiness in the Little House books for me though? Is that what I didn't like about them--a preponderance of the sort of can-do individualism that led Rose W Lane to being a libertarian in old age?
Did that ring false to me?
I think maybe so. I liked grimmer stories. (There's no false cheer in Island of the Blue Dolphins, it's almost emotionally flat.) Of the LH series, I liked best The Long Winter, which is the frightening record of a winter when the Ingalls family almost starved to death.
(Similarly in Maud Hart Lovelace's Betsy-Tacy series, I liked best the related Emily of Deep Valley. Betsy & Tacy head off to college, and Emily is trapped at home. Though she makes good, it's a much bleaker story.)
The differences are nowhere near this stark, not at all! but I think of how Truman Capote was fascinated by Perry Smith, the murderer In Cold Blood who shared his background but went in a different direction. Capote wrote, "It's as if Perry and I grew up in the same house. And one day he stood up and went out the back door, while I went out the front."
I've read some books in the past about the Ingalls/Wilder clan, and I knew I had a negative impression of Rose, but I couldn't remember why. Then you mentioned her politics!
ReplyDeleteI only ever read the first two Little House books, and I did love them. But for some reason I never felt the need to go farther with the series. (This is my reading pattern for all books in a series -- I seldom go beyond the first few. There's too much out there to read to get stuck with a single series or author!)
Funny you mentioned "Island of the Blue Dolphins" being emotionally flat. It is, now that you say that, but I loved it as a kid. I remember it being quite moving, but didn't have quite the same experience when I read it as an adult. Maybe it's more subtle than flat.
hi Steve!
DeleteI loved Island of the Blue dolphins as a kid too—and was a little bored by it but still liked it when I reread it last month.
“Subtle” is a good word for it—very subtle for children—a very few mentions of Karana being sad or lonely, but no emotional scenes of her weeping or anything.
wow, another book to read. i remember reading (i think) LH but don't remember becoming obsessed by it. and couldn't stand the tv version with michael landon.
ReplyDeletefor another view of life on the prairie - find this book: the quilters women and domestic art. they spoke to women who had grown up in the midwest and lived in the sod houses. i remember one of them who said: it was not romantic at all and horrible to live in. the dirt came in no matter how you tried to keep it out. you lived in a sod house until you could have enough money to buy the lumber to build a house. also to get batting for their quilts, they collected what was left in fields or from fences near the mills. the family would card it and piece their batting together.
the two movies on truman capote are fascinating to watch how he was enamored(?) of Perry. in cold blood was actually the last book he wrote. oddly i have never read in cold blood and never plan to. i don't think i need that in my head. we moved to kansas 8 years after it happened and i have found more people here who had connections to the cutter family. a friend of my brother's mother taught sunday school to the cutter children. and to think that one of them had left for college and then to be told that all of your family was killed. my mother based off of that murder/book also told me one of my life lessons i tend to follow: never tell people what you have of value.
kirsten
KIRSTEN: I wouldn’t particularly recommend “Pioneer Girl”—but it’s an interesting topic.
DeleteThat book Quilters sounds great!
I never saw LH tv show—it looked dreadful! PG mentions how far from the book it goes, into ridiculous modern lot twists.
I don’t intend to ever read “In Cold Blood” either! 😳I loved the Philip Seymour Hoffman movie but never saw the second one—I should!
Another beautifully written post.
ReplyDeleteI never read any of the Little House books- was not exposed to them. I'm sure I would have loved them.
What you said about the "cheerful can-do pluckiness" made me think of Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings' book, "The Yearling" which is also the story of a pioneer family but one in Florida. Have you ever read it? It is not cheerful for the most part and there is much grimness in it. It remains one of my favorite books to this day.
Hi MS MOON:
DeleteI haven’t read Little House as an adult but it’s still super popular—maybe something to read with the grands?
Maybe skip the second one, which from “Pioneer Girl” I’m reminded is full of White Mans Destiny shit about Indians?
Still, the author of PG loves the series.
Laura IW’s name has been taken off some honors because of that, but as I say, I haven’t reread the series and don’t know how prevalent it is.
PS MS MOON: oh,,yes, I read The Yearling! I remember a sense of foreign-to-me landscape and of course another of those traumatic tales of animal death, like Old Yeller. I vaguely remember the movie too—Gregory Peck is good at playing sadder but wiser fathers!
Deleteoh, you have to watch the other truman movie -- infamous. oddly both came out in the same year. infamous is based on the george plimpton book about capote. daniel craig plays perry smith and sandra bullock is harper lee. toby jones is truman and plays him quite differently than philip seymour hoffman.
ReplyDeletefun fact i just found out about infamous: one of the scenes has capote and lee ordering a drink in a holcomb ks resturant in the 60's. oops-- couldn't do that then. you had to be a member of a private club and no drinks in restaurants. it was until the 80s that that started changing. airlines also couldn't serve drinks until they were out of the kansas airspace. true story thanks to our then AG Vern Miller (https://vernmiller.com/).
kirsten
KIRSTEN: oooo I just watched the trailer for “Infamous”—-it looks super good! I love Toby Jones (The Detectirists etc)—and HopeDavis too!
DeleteI also put a hold on “The Quilters” at the library
Thanks!